Most patients walk into a physiotherapy clinic expecting the safest part of their treatment. There is no scalpel and no anaesthetic; the goal is simply to ease a stiff back, loosen a frozen shoulder, or rebuild strength in a knee after surgery. Yet some patients leave a session worse than they arrived: a burn from a hot pack or a heat device, a skin injury from an electrical stimulation unit, a torn tendon or ligament after an over-aggressive exercise, a dislocated joint after forced mobilisation, or a fracture made worse by traction that ignored the patient's history. At that point the question is no longer "when will I feel better?" but "who is responsible for what happened to me?"
The question is harder in physiotherapy than in many other areas of medicine because the patient usually deals with three parties at once. There is the referring doctor (an orthopaedic surgeon, a neurologist or a rehabilitation physician) who diagnosed the condition, wrote the referral and may have set the treatment plan and its restrictions. There is the physiotherapist who actually carried out the session by hand and with equipment. And there is the clinic or hospital that employs the physiotherapist, owns the machines and organises the work. Each of them may point at the others: the therapist says they followed the referral, the doctor says the plan was sound and the execution was wrong, and the clinic says the injury was a known complication.
This article deals with that specific situation under Kuwaiti law. It does not repeat the general rules of medical liability, which we covered in Medical Liability in Kuwaiti Law, nor the problem of poor follow-up after surgery, which has its own article on neglected post-operative follow-up and early discharge. Instead, it focuses on the nature of the physiotherapist's duty, when a mistake becomes an established fault, how responsibility is shared with the referring doctor and the clinic, how the patient proves the case, how a known complication differs from negligence, and which administrative, civil and criminal routes are open. It closes with three hypothetical cases and a set of frequently asked questions.
The Short Answer
Like a doctor, a physiotherapist is in principle bound by an obligation of means, not an obligation of result. They do not guarantee recovery or the disappearance of pain, but they are liable if they depart from what a careful physiotherapist of the same level would have done in the same circumstances. Fault is usually established where the therapist exceeded the referring doctor's instructions or the limits in the treatment plan, applied pressure or traction out of proportion to the patient's condition, failed to set up and monitor a heat or electrical device so that the patient was burned, or ignored a previous fracture, a recent operation or a condition that rules out a particular exercise.
Responsibility follows the source of the error. The referring doctor answers for a referral or plan that was itself wrong or omitted essential restrictions and warnings. The physiotherapist answers for errors in carrying out the treatment. The clinic or hospital answers for the fault of its staff as their principal, and for its own fault in maintaining equipment, employing unqualified or unlicensed people, or operating without a licence. In most cases the practical approach is to sue all the potential defendants together and let the court, assisted by technical expert evidence, decide each one's share.
Three routes are available: an administrative complaint to the Ministry of Health and its competent technical bodies; a civil claim for material and moral damages; and a criminal complaint where the facts amount to causing injury by negligence or practising a health profession without a licence. The most important immediate steps are to document the injury with photographs and a medical report, request a complete copy of the physiotherapy file and the session plan, and sign no settlement or release before the full extent of the harm is known.
The Legal Framework
Kuwait has no separate statute dedicated to physiotherapy errors. These cases are governed by a combination of general and specialised legislation:
- The Civil Code (Decree-Law No. 67/1980) is the main source for compensation. It contains the rules on tort liability (fault, damage and causation), contractual liability where the patient has a treatment contract with the clinic, the rule that a principal is liable for the acts of its agent or employee (which makes the clinic or hospital answerable for the physiotherapist working on its behalf), the rules on liability for things whose custody requires special care, and the rules for assessing material and moral damages.
- The law regulating the practice of medicine, the allied health professions and patients' rights governs licensing of health professions, including physiotherapy, sets out the duties practitioners owe to patients, recognises the patient's right to information and to their medical file, and penalises practice without a licence. Reference should be made to its official text in force for the details; licensing questions are also discussed in our article on the regulation of health professions in Kuwait.
- The Penal Code (Law No. 16/1960) criminalises causing injury by negligence, recklessness, lack of precaution or failure to observe regulations. It is the basis for a criminal complaint in serious physiotherapy cases.
- The Code of Criminal Procedure (Law No. 17/1960) governs complaints and investigations and allows the injured person to join a civil claim to the criminal proceedings.
- The Law of Evidence in Civil and Commercial Matters (Law No. 39/1980) governs the appointment of experts, the evidential weight of documents, and requests to order an opponent to produce a document in its possession, which matters when the clinic holds the treatment file.
- The Civil and Commercial Procedure Code (Law No. 38/1980) governs filing suits and court jurisdiction, including urgent applications to record the state of an injury before its features change.
- Ministerial decisions and Ministry of Health regulations cover licensing requirements for physiotherapy and rehabilitation centres, staff qualifications, and the work of the technical committees that examine complaints of medical error. A breach of these rules is strong evidence of fault.
The competent court and the correct way of suing a government body differ depending on whether the sessions took place in a public hospital or a private clinic. That is a procedural matter for the lawyer to determine on the facts of each case.
Substantive Rules: Who Is Liable for What?
1. The nature of the physiotherapist's duty
The physiotherapist's core obligation is one of reasonable care. The outcome of rehabilitation depends on many factors beyond the therapist's control: the nature of the injury, the patient's age, whether the home exercise programme is followed and how the body responds. A patient cannot establish liability simply by saying "I did not improve". But the standard of care is not that of an ordinary person; it is the care exercised by a diligent physiotherapist of average knowledge and experience in the profession, in line with settled professional and scientific practice, taking account of the surrounding circumstances.
Some commentators argue that certain ancillary duties in physiotherapy come close to an obligation of result, most notably the duty to ensure that equipment and tools are safe: a patient who goes in for heat therapy should not come out with a burn caused by a faulty machine. Others take the view that the duty remains one of care, but with a stricter standard. Which characterisation applies in a given case is for the court to decide in light of the facts and the expert report. In practice, however, the patient's burden of proof is considerably lighter where the injury was caused by a device rather than by a clinical judgement.
2. Situations in which fault is usually established
- Exceeding the referring doctor's instructions: for example, the referral prohibits weight-bearing or limits the range of motion after surgery, and the therapist goes beyond those limits.
- Excessive pressure or traction: forced mobilisation of a joint, or mechanical traction of the neck or back with force unsuited to the patient's condition, age or bone density, or continuing despite the patient's complaint of sharp, unusual pain.
- Heat and electrical devices: placing a hot pack without adequate insulation or for too long, setting the intensity of an electrical stimulator or ultrasound unit incorrectly, using it on an area with reduced sensation, on damaged skin or over implanted metal without due precaution, or leaving the patient unattended.
- Ignoring the patient's condition: performing exercises or manual techniques on a patient with a previous fracture, severe osteoporosis, a deep vein thrombosis or another contraindication, where this was recorded in the referral or could have been discovered by a simple question at the initial assessment.
- Neglecting assessment and monitoring: starting sessions without a documented initial assessment, or failing to notice obvious signs of deterioration and to refer the patient back to the doctor.
- Failing to inform: not explaining the risks of a particular technique or not obtaining the patient's agreement. We discussed this principle in the surgical context in our article on informed consent, and it applies, with adjustments, to physiotherapy.
3. The referring doctor's liability
The referring doctor is not automatically liable for everything that happens in physiotherapy, since they do not perform the sessions. They are, however, liable for their own fault. Examples include referring without an adequate diagnosis, such as sending a patient for intensive exercise before ruling out a fracture or a disc problem that requires different treatment; omitting essential restrictions and warnings from the plan, such as failing to state that weight-bearing is prohibited after surgical fixation; starting rehabilitation earlier than the wound or bone allows; and ignoring reports from the therapist indicating deterioration. Where a faulty referral combines with faulty execution, the court may hold both liable according to the role each played.
4. The clinic's or hospital's liability
The liability of the clinic or hospital rests on two complementary grounds:
- Liability of the principal for its employee: where the physiotherapist works for the clinic, under its supervision and direction, the clinic is liable for faults committed in the course of, or because of, that work, and may afterwards seek recovery from the therapist. We explained the conditions of this liability in our article on vicarious liability of the principal.
- The institution's own fault: failing to maintain or calibrate heat and electrical equipment, employing unlicensed or unqualified staff or trainees without supervision, assigning so many patients to one therapist that proper monitoring becomes impossible, lacking safety protocols, or operating without a licence at all.
Where the patient contracted directly with the clinic and paid for the sessions, liability may also be contractual. Opinions differ on whether the contractual or tortious basis should prevail, and the choice can affect some procedural details, but the substance of the patient's protection exists either way.
5. Known complication or negligence?
Some temporary pain and swelling after sessions is expected, particularly in the first weeks after an operation. The therapist is not liable for a recognised complication that occurred despite proper professional practice, provided the patient was reasonably informed of it. But where the harm is unusual in its nature or severity, results from the breach of a clear safety rule, or was a genuine complication that the therapist was slow to recognise and manage, it moves from "complication" to "fault". The deciding factor is the technical expert evidence, not the patient's impression or the clinic's defence.
6. Causation and the patient's own fault
It must be shown that the harm resulted from the fault and not from the natural course of the condition. The clinic may argue that the patient contributed, for example by concealing a previous fracture or operation, ignoring the home exercise instructions, or lifting prohibited weights. If proven, the court may reduce compensation in proportion to the patient's contribution, or reject liability altogether if the patient's own fault was the sole cause. That is why accurate disclosure of medical history from the first session matters.
7. Heads of compensation
Compensation in principle covers all direct harm: the cost of corrective treatment, operations and additional sessions; loss of earnings, such as days off work or reduced earning capacity; physical harm, such as disability or scarring from a burn; moral damage, such as pain, suffering and embarrassment; and in some cases loss of a chance of recovery that was realistically available, an idea explained in our article on misdiagnosis and lost chance of treatment. The amount is assessed by the trial court in light of the medical reports and the patient's circumstances.
Principles Settled by the Court of Cassation
Based on the general approach of the Kuwaiti Court of Cassation in medical and professional liability, the following principles can be stated. They apply to physiotherapy as an allied health profession:
- The Court of Cassation has consistently held that the obligation of a doctor, and of other licensed health practitioners, is one of reasonable care, measured by what a diligent professional of average knowledge would do in the same circumstances, in accordance with settled professional practice.
- It has held that whether professional fault and causation are established is a question of fact for the trial court, provided its reasoning is sound and grounded in the case file.
- It has held that the trial court may rely on an expert's or a technical committee's report if it is satisfied with it, and may set it aside or appoint another expert if it finds the report deficient, provided it gives reasons.
- It has held that a principal is liable for its employee's fault committed in the course of, or because of, the employee's duties, and that the injured party may claim directly against the principal without first suing the employee.
- It has held that assessing compensation for material and moral damage falls within the trial court's discretion, provided it identifies the elements of harm it took into account.
Methodological note: These principles are stated in general terms and reflect well-known trends in Cassation case law on medical and civil liability. No specific judgment numbers are cited. They should not be relied upon in a pleading or claim without consulting the original judgments from official sources and confirming that they fit the facts, as the outcome of each case depends on its own details and expert evidence.
Practical Steps and Documents
Step one: treatment and immediate documentation
Your health comes first. Get treatment straight away, preferably at a medical facility independent of the clinic where the injury happened, and ask for a written medical report describing the injury, its type, its severity and its date. Photograph the burn, swelling or bruising clearly, with dates, and repeat the photographs over time, because burns change in appearance over the following days. Write down your own account of the session: which device was used, how long the session lasted, the therapist's name, whether you complained during the session, and how they responded.
Step two: obtain the complete treatment file
Ask for a full copy of your file at the clinic, especially the doctor's referral, the initial assessment, the physiotherapy plan, and the record of each session, including the equipment, its settings and the exercises performed, together with any consent form you signed. Patients are entitled to see their medical file and obtain a copy. If the clinic refuses, see our article on a hospital refusing to release the medical file. Keep payment receipts, messages exchanged with the clinic, and any earlier imaging that shows your condition before the sessions.
Step three: administrative complaint
A complaint can be filed with the Ministry of Health, which refers it to the technical bodies responsible for examining complaints of medical error. You can also report a clinic that operates without a licence or employs unlicensed staff. A technical committee's report is not a binding court judgment, but it is important technical evidence that can be submitted to the court, either relied upon or challenged.
Step four: criminal route where appropriate
Where the injury is serious, the fault is clear, or the person who treated you was unlicensed, a criminal complaint can be filed for causing injury by negligence or for unlicensed practice. The injured person may join a civil claim to the criminal case or keep the civil claim for the civil courts. Choosing the right route, or combining them, requires professional judgement based on the strength of the evidence.
Step five: civil claim and expert evidence
The compensation claim is brought against all the potential defendants together: the physiotherapist, the clinic or hospital, and the referring doctor where the plan played a part. The court usually appoints a medical expert or refers the matter to a technical body to identify the fault, the causal link and any degree of permanent disability; we explain the process in our article on medical expert evidence before Kuwaiti courts. If the features of the injury are likely to change or disappear, an urgent application to record its condition may be made.
A note on time limits
Compensation claims and criminal complaints are subject to limitation and forfeiture periods, some of which run from the date the injured person learned of the harm and of the person responsible. Do not delay, and speak to a lawyer early to identify the period that applies to your case.
Document checklist
- Proof of identity and standing (the patient, a guardian, or heirs).
- The referral, the physiotherapy plan and the session records.
- Any consent forms.
- Medical reports after the injury, and imaging before and after it.
- Dated photographs of the injury and how it developed.
- Payment receipts and invoices for corrective treatment.
- Evidence of time off work or loss of income.
- Names of witnesses, such as a companion who attended the session.
- Any material on the licensing of the clinic and the therapist, if in doubt.
Three Hypothetical Cases
Case one: a burn from a heat device
A woman in her fifties with chronic lower back pain is referred by her doctor for physiotherapy including heat and electrical stimulation. In one session the therapist places a hot pack on her back, leaves to attend another patient, and when she complains that it is very hot, tells her that this is normal. The next day blisters appear and develop into a second-degree burn that requires treatment at a burns unit and leaves a visible scar. Analysis: professional practice requires adequate insulating layers, monitoring of the skin and a response to the patient's complaints. Leaving the patient unattended and dismissing her complaint strongly suggests fault. The therapist is liable for their own fault, and the clinic is liable as principal; it may also be liable for its own fault if the therapist's patient load made monitoring impossible or the equipment was defective. The referring doctor usually has no role, since the referral for heat therapy was itself appropriate. The claim covers treatment of the burn, moral damage, and compensation for scarring if it proves permanent.
Case two: a tear after excessive exercise following surgery
A man undergoes anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. The surgeon's referral states that rehabilitation should begin with limited-range exercises and that certain exercises are prohibited in the first phase. The clinic assigns a newly hired therapist who does not read the restrictions carefully and subjects the patient to forced flexion and heavy resistance. The patient feels a pop and sharp pain, and a later MRI shows failure of the graft requiring a second operation. Analysis: exceeding written restrictions in the referral is a clear error of execution. The therapist is liable, and the clinic is liable as principal and possibly for its own failure to supervise a new employee. The clinic will probably argue that graft failure is a recognised complication that can occur even with correct rehabilitation. The expert report then becomes decisive: did the failure result from exercise contrary to the restrictions, or would it have happened anyway? Had the referral omitted the restrictions altogether, part of the liability would shift to the referring surgeon. The claim covers the cost of the second operation, time off work, moral damage and the lost chance of recovery.
Case three: sessions at an unlicensed centre
A young man with neck pain sees a social media advertisement for cheap "manipulation and physiotherapy sessions" in a residential flat. The person running the place performs forceful neck manipulation without any examination or imaging. Afterwards the patient suffers severe dizziness and numbness in his arm, and further treatment over a long period is needed. He later discovers that the premises are unlicensed and that the person who treated him holds no practising licence. Analysis: practising without a licence is an offence in itself that may give rise to criminal liability, and it is strong evidence of fault, because a person without a licence offers no guarantee of the required training. The person who treated him is liable for their fault, and so is whoever runs or owns the premises if that is someone else. An argument that the patient "chose" a cheap option is generally not accepted, since a patient's consent cannot authorise unlicensed practice of a health profession. The practical difficulty is enforcement rather than entitlement: the person responsible may lack the means to pay, so it is important to identify the people behind the premises early and to report them to the competent authorities.
Comparison: Who Answers for What?
- The physiotherapist: errors of execution, such as exceeding restrictions, excessive pressure or traction, incorrect device settings, leaving the patient unattended, poor assessment, and failing to refer the patient back to the doctor when deterioration appears.
- The referring doctor: errors in the referral and plan, such as an incomplete diagnosis, omission of essential restrictions, an unsuitably early start, and failure to follow up despite signs of deterioration.
- The private clinic or hospital: vicarious liability for the therapist's fault, plus its own fault in equipment maintenance, staff qualification and supervision, patient load and licensing; contractual liability may also arise where it contracted with the patient.
- The public hospital: the government body concerned is liable as principal for its employees' fault, subject to the special procedures for suing government bodies.
- A known complication: no compensation if it occurred despite proper practice and the patient was informed; it becomes fault if it is unusual, results from a breach of a safety rule, or is mismanaged.
- The patient: may bear part of the harm if they concealed their history or ignored instructions, reducing compensation accordingly.
- Administrative route: complaint, technical report and possible disciplinary action, usually without direct compensation.
- Civil route: the main path to compensation.
- Criminal route: punishment for causing injury by negligence or unlicensed practice, which can be combined with a civil claim.
For comparison with errors by other allied health professionals, see our article on pharmacist dispensing errors, and our article on patients and visitors falling inside a health facility if the injury came from a fall off a treatment table or a treadmill.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a physiotherapist guarantee that I will recover or that the pain will go?
No. The obligation is in principle one of reasonable care in line with professional practice, not one of result. A lack of improvement alone is not enough to establish liability, but a new injury caused by an error in treatment is a different matter.
I was burned by a heat device. Do I have to prove a complicated fault?
A burn from a device or hot pack is usually regarded as outside the normal course, because proper practice requires insulation and monitoring. You still have to prove the injury and its link to the session, but your position is generally stronger than in cases involving clinical judgement, with the final assessment resting with the court and the expert report.
Should I sue the physiotherapist or the clinic?
It is usually best to sue both, together with the referring doctor if the plan played a part. The clinic is liable as principal and is usually better able to pay, the therapist is liable for their own fault, and the court allocates responsibility according to the evidence.
The therapist says they only followed the doctor's plan. Who is responsible?
If the plan itself was wrong or omitted essential restrictions, the referring doctor may be liable. But following a plan does not relieve the therapist of the professional duty to assess and pay attention; if there were clear signs that the exercise should not be performed and they were ignored, liability may be shared.
Does every pain or swelling after a session mean there was a mistake?
No. Some temporary pain and swelling is expected, especially after surgery. Fault arises when the harm goes beyond the normal in type or severity, results from breaching a safety rule, or when the therapist ignores signs of deterioration. Distinguishing the two is the role of expert evidence.
I signed a consent form before the sessions. Have I lost my rights?
A consent form shows that you accepted the treatment and its recognised risks, but it does not exempt the provider from liability for errors or negligence in carrying it out. Advance exclusion of liability for serious fault causing bodily harm is highly questionable in law, and its effect depends on the wording and the circumstances.
The clinic is offering free sessions if I waive my claim. Should I accept?
Do not sign any settlement or waiver before your treatment is complete, you know the true extent of the harm, and you have spoken to a lawyer. The permanent effects of a burn or tear may only become clear later, and a waiver could deprive you of compensation for them.
What if the sessions were at a public hospital?
The right to compensation remains. The government body is liable as principal for its employees' fault, subject to the special procedures for suing it. An administrative complaint to the Ministry of Health can be filed alongside.
How can I check whether a clinic or therapist is licensed?
You can ask the Ministry of Health about the facility's licence and the therapist's practising licence, and licences are normally expected to be displayed at the facility. Proof that a licence was missing is an important element in both a complaint and a claim.
Is the Ministry of Health committee's report binding on the court?
Not in itself. It is technical evidence that the court weighs; the court may rely on it or appoint another expert, and each party may challenge it and point out its shortcomings.
Can I claim for emotional suffering and not just expenses?
Yes. Compensation in principle covers moral damage such as pain, suffering and embarrassment from scarring, as well as material loss such as treatment costs and lost earnings. The court assesses it according to the circumstances.
I did not tell the therapist about an old fracture. Have I lost my claim?
Concealing material information may be treated as your own fault, reducing or excluding compensation depending on how much it contributed to the harm. But if the information was in the referral or would have emerged from an ordinary initial assessment, the therapist may still bear part of the responsibility.
Can I sue only the referring doctor?
Yes, if the harm came from an error in the referral or plan, such as omitting an essential restriction. But if the execution was at fault, a claim against the doctor alone may fail, which is why it is generally better to sue all the parties together.
Conclusion
Physiotherapy is an essential stage of recovery, but it is not a liability-free zone. A physiotherapist is a licensed health professional who owes a duty of reasonable care according to the standards of the profession, and who is liable for exceeding the doctor's instructions, using force unsuited to the patient's condition, mishandling heat and electrical equipment, or ignoring an obvious pre-existing condition.
Responsibility follows the source of the error: the referring doctor for the plan, the therapist for its execution, and the clinic or hospital for its staff, its equipment, the qualifications of its personnel and its licensing. The practical course for the patient is to sue the parties together, rely on the treatment file, later medical reports, technical committee findings and court-appointed expert evidence, and leave it to the court to allocate liability and assess compensation.
The key points to remember are simple: document the injury immediately, request your complete treatment file, get treated at an independent facility, sign no waiver before the extent of the harm is known, and do not delay. To compare this type of liability with other medical errors, see our article on anaesthesia complications and errors.
Legal Disclaimer
This article provides general legal information on Kuwaiti law. It is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship. The rules described are subject to legislative change and to judicial application on the facts of each case, and the medical assessment of any injury is a matter for qualified specialists.
If you or a family member were injured during physiotherapy sessions, the team at Yumnaak Law Firm can review the treatment file and session plan, identify the responsible parties, pursue a complaint before the competent authorities, bring a civil or criminal case, and claim compensation. Contact us or book an appointment to discuss your case at our office.