Annual Efficiency Report for Government Employees in Kuwait: What If the Rating Is Weak or Unfair, and How to Grieve and Challenge It Before the Administrative Circuit

Received a weak or unfair annual efficiency rating in Kuwait? A practical guide to seeing the report, grieving it, challenging it before the Administrative Circuit, and its effect on promotion, increments and transfer.

At the end of each evaluation cycle, many government employees in Kuwait receive what looks like a routine administrative form: the annual performance (efficiency) report. Yet this single sheet can be the most consequential document in a service file. The rating it records is the foundation on which later decisions about promotion, the periodic increment, training nominations and senior posts are built, and it may also be invoked to justify a transfer or to sideline an employee. If the rating is weak, or clearly lower than the employee deserves, silence is costly: the effect accumulates year after year, and the employee often notices only when passed over for a promotion or denied an increment.

The question we hear most often is simple: can an employee object to a superior's opinion of their competence? Is the rating not a purely subjective matter that falls within the administration's discretion? The answer is that the administration does hold wide discretion in assessing performance, but the discretion is not absolute. It is bound by objective criteria set by the Civil Service Law and its regulations, by procedures that must be respected, and by the principle that an administrative decision may not be used to settle a personal quarrel, to retaliate against an employee, or to clear the way to denying a right. When a rating steps outside these limits it can be challenged, first by an administrative grievance and then before the Administrative Circuit of the Court of First Instance.

This article focuses on that specific angle: the annual report as an evaluation tool and as a possible source of injustice; how the employee comes to know of it and to see it; how to grieve and then sue; what the court reviews and what it leaves to the administration; and how the rating affects promotion, the increment and transfer. We do not repeat topics covered in our earlier articles on disciplinary penalties imposed without investigation, negative administrative decisions, arbitrary transfers and being passed over for promotion; we refer to them where relevant.

Quick Answer

The efficiency report is the instrument through which a government entity periodically evaluates its employees. It is prepared by the direct superior, reviewed by a higher one and approved at the level the regulations specify. The employee is entitled to know the rating, to see the report, and to challenge it through the route set by the executive regulations of the Civil Service Law, which is usually an internal grievance before a committee or a higher authority within the same entity.

If the grievance fails, or the entity stays silent, or it maintains the rating, the employee may sue before the Administrative Circuit of the Court of First Instance, challenging the rating itself where it qualifies as a final decision affecting their legal position, together with the decisions built on it, such as being passed over for promotion or having the increment withheld. The court does not replace the superior's judgment of how well the employee performed. It reviews legality: was the rating issued by the competent person and through the correct procedure? Does it rest on facts that are actually established in the file? Is it tainted by misuse of power, arbitrariness, or the absence of any reasonable basis for a sudden drop?

The most important practical rule is: do not wait. Grievances and suits are subject to statutory time limits, and missing them shields even an unfair rating from review. What strengthens the employee's position is the record: earlier reports, certificates, documented achievements and a comparison of the new rating with the employee's entire history.

Legislative Framework

Several complementary instruments govern this question:

  • The Civil Service Law (Decree-Law No. 15 of 1979) and its executive regulations: the primary source for the periodic evaluation of civil servants, the conditions for promotion and the periodic increment, the effect of the rating on each of them, the authorities that prepare and approve reports, and the internal grievance mechanisms. We outlined its general provisions in our article on the Civil Service Law and the rights and duties of the government employee.
  • The Administrative Circuit Law (Decree-Law No. 20 of 1981): establishes the Administrative Circuit within the Court of First Instance and gives it jurisdiction over challenges to final administrative decisions concerning employees, including promotion and passing-over decisions and disputes about salaries and increments. Challenges rest on the recognised grounds of illegality: lack of competence, violation of the law, a defect of form, or misuse of power.
  • Regulations and decisions of the Civil Service Council and the Civil Service Commission: these set the report forms, the evaluation criteria, the scale of ratings and the effect of each rating on career rights. Details vary by employee category and entity, and some bodies with special pay scales have their own evaluation rules, so the instrument that actually applies to the employee must be checked.
  • The Civil and Commercial Procedure Law (No. 38 of 1980): consulted for procedural matters on which the Administrative Circuit Law is silent.

These statutes are read together with the general principles developed by the administrative judiciary, foremost among them that an administrative decision must rest on a sound cause justified in fact and in law, and that its purpose must be the public interest rather than personal whim. We covered the wider set of career safeguards in our article on the legal safeguards for the transferred employee, which helps place the employee's relationship with the entity in context.

Substantive Rules

1. What is an efficiency report and why is it prepared?

An efficiency report, also called a performance report, is a periodic document prepared for each employee for a defined period. It assesses performance and professional conduct against elements set by the regulations: output and accuracy, attendance and discipline, ability to bear responsibility, dealings with superiors, colleagues and the public, initiative and self-development. It ends in an overall rating on a scale that runs from an outstanding level to a weak one, labelled differently depending on the entity and the period.

The legislative purpose is twofold: to give the administration an objective basis for comparing employees for promotion, increments and training, and to alert the employee to weaknesses so they can be corrected. In principle it is a tool of fairness and development and must not become disguised punishment. That distinction matters in litigation: if the rating was used to punish an employee for something unrelated to performance, it has strayed from its purpose.

2. Who prepares it and who approves it?

In general terms, the direct superior begins the report because he or she is closest to the employee's work. It then goes to a higher superior who reviews it and records an opinion, and is finally approved by the authority the regulations name, which may be the department director, the undersecretary or a specialised committee, depending on the entity and the grade. Some systems also use committees to review reports with exceptional ratings, high or low, to prevent exaggeration in either direction.

Knowing this chain matters because each stage has a role that can be invoked. If a higher superior lowered the direct superior's rating, did he or she give reasons? If the person who prepared the report was not in fact the employee's superior or did not supervise the employee during the period, that may support a challenge based on competence or on the soundness of the basis of the rating. The exact chain in a particular entity is a matter for the regulations that apply to it and for the report form itself.

3. The employee's knowledge of the report and right to see it

As a rule, decisions affecting an employee's legal position do not produce their effect against the employee, and the time limits for challenging them do not run, until the employee has actual knowledge of them, by notification, delivery of a copy or any means proving knowledge of their content and grounds. It follows that an entity which keeps a weak rating in the file without telling its subject is in a weak position: an employee cannot fairly be held to a rating he or she was never allowed to contest.

Regulations typically provide that the rating is presented to the employee, who signs as having seen it, and that the employee may read the report and its remarks so that a grievance can be made. Signing is evidence of knowledge only. It does not mean acceptance and does not waive the right to grieve. A common mistake is to refuse to sign out of anger; the superior then records the refusal and the entity counts knowledge from the date of presentation. The safer course is to sign as having seen it, write a clear statement that you are grieving the rating, and keep a copy.

If the entity refuses to let the employee see the report or obtain a copy, the employee may request it in writing with a registered receipt number. Refusal or silence can be relied on later and may fall within the concept of a negative decision, whose rules we discussed in our article on government silence and the implied refusal. In litigation, moreover, the court can order the entity to produce the report and the papers behind it, so the entity cannot withhold what supports or undermines its position.

4. The administrative grievance

Regulations generally provide an internal administrative route for grievances against efficiency reports, usually to a grievance committee or to the higher authority the regulations designate, within the period set for it. This route reviews the rating on its merits and appropriateness, more broadly than a court does: the committee may reconsider the level of performance itself and raise or maintain the rating, whereas the court will not, as explained below. It is therefore a stage that should never be wasted; it may do justice without a lawsuit.

The grievance should be written and specific. It states the employee's name, post and the date on which he or she learned of the rating; identifies the elements objected to; attaches evidence for each objection (an earlier higher rating, documented achievements, the absence of any earlier written remark that could justify a reduction); and expressly asks for reconsideration of the rating, correction of the report and removal of its effect from the file. It should be submitted by a method that fixes the date, such as registration in the entity's correspondence log with an outgoing and incoming number.

An express rejection is a decision from which the time for challenge begins. If the entity stays silent and does not decide within the period the law sets, the silence is treated as an implied rejection and the employee may sue on that basis. We explained the implied refusal and the counting of deadlines in the article mentioned above. What is said of pre-suit grievances in civil service cases generally applies here too, and it is unwise to skip the grievance on the assumption that it is not required: if it was required, skipping it can lead to the case being dismissed as inadmissible.

5. Challenging the rating before the Administrative Circuit

If the grievance route is exhausted without result, the employee files an annulment action before the Administrative Circuit of the Court of First Instance, through a lawyer, asking for the contested decision and its consequences to be annulled and, where its elements are met, compensation for resulting harm. What is contested is either the rating itself or the decision built on it, such as the promotion decision that passed the employee over, the withholding of the increment or a nomination the employee was denied.

There is a delicate admissibility point: is an efficiency report challenged on its own, or only through the decision it produced? The administrative courts have taken differing approaches that turn on how the report is characterised. Some treat it as an internal preparatory step that cannot be challenged independently unless it directly affects the employee's legal position; others treat it as a final decision once it is approved, communicated and has produced its effect. This article does not purport to settle that disagreement, which in practice is left to the court's assessment in each case. The practical precaution is to include every related decision in the claim: the rating and the decision built on it, so the case cannot fall to a formal objection.

Before ruling on the merits, the Administrative Circuit may order a stay of execution of the contested decision if the conditions of seriousness and urgency are met. That can matter when the effect is imminent, for example a promotion about to be issued to a colleague that the rating is blocking. In most cases the action ends in a merits judgment; if annulment is granted the entity must reconsider the matter in line with the judgment, which in turn affects promotion and the increment.

6. Judicial review of the rating: what the court reviews and what it does not

The administration is best placed to judge how well its employees perform, because it is closer to the work and its standards. So the court does not intervene on appropriateness: it will not say that the employee deserves "good" rather than "average," because that would substitute the judge's assessment for the administration's. It does review legality, which includes the following.

  • Competence and procedure: was the report prepared by someone entitled to prepare it? Did it pass through the stages the regulations require: direct superior, reviewer, approving authority? Was the employee able to see it and grieve it? Breach of an essential procedure can invalidate the rating.
  • Accuracy of the facts (the cause): do the weak elements of the rating rest on facts established in the file? If the report refers to "repeated lateness" or "failure in duties" and nothing in the file supports it, the rating has lost its cause.
  • Misuse of power: where a decision appears to serve the public interest but actually pursues another aim, such as retaliation against an employee who filed a complaint or refused to carry out an unlawful instruction, settling a personal dispute, or making room for someone's promotion. The burden of proving it lies on the claimant, and it is among the hardest defects to prove because it concerns the decision-maker's intent; it is usually inferred from circumstances rather than from an admission.
  • Arbitrariness and the absence of a reasonable basis: for instance a sudden fall from a high rating held steadily for years to a weak one, with no change in the work or performance and no written remarks, or evaluation against criteria that do not apply to the employee's post. Such features raise an inference that the rating was not based on a serious assessment.
  • Lack of reasons: the general rule is that an administrative decision need not state reasons unless the law says so, but regulations may require reasons from anyone who lowers a rating or awards an exceptional one. In any event the court readily asks for the reasons behind a decision once it is challenged, and if the entity cannot show a justification for the reduction in its papers, its position weakens. This point requires checking the applicable regulation; no duty to give reasons should be assumed unless a provision imposes one.

7. Effect of the rating on promotion, the increment and transfer

Promotion. Promotion does not rest on the rating alone: it is combined with other conditions such as seniority, time in grade, qualifications and a clean record within the limits the regulations set. A weak rating can nevertheless be a bar or a factor weighing against the employee in the comparison, especially where the latest reports are the yardstick for ranking competitors. The case of an employee passed over for a more junior colleague is treated in our article on promotion of a more junior or less competent colleague, so we do not repeat it here; it is enough to know that grieving the rating is often the first step in reopening the path to promotion.

The periodic increment. Regulations link the periodic increment to the efficiency rating, so that a good rating or above is a condition for receiving it in full, and a lower rating may prevent, delay or reduce it, depending on the rule applied. Withholding an increment because of an unfair rating is therefore a direct financial effect that can be challenged, and if the challenge succeeds in the underlying matter the employee is entitled to the differences that follow from correcting it, in accordance with the judgment and the applicable rules. Financial differences, once due, raise practical questions of payment and recovery, whose reverse side we treated in our article on repaying a salary or allowance paid by mistake.

Transfer, secondment and posts. A weak rating may be used as a pretext to move an employee to a less important position or to keep the employee off the promotion track. Where a transfer is tied to an unfair rating, that supports a plea of misuse of power. We examined the conditions for lawful and unlawful transfer in our article on arbitrary transfer or secondment. A weak rating that reflects genuine shortcomings must also be distinguished from a disciplinary penalty, which has its own procedures and safeguards: an entity may not use a weak rating to avoid the safeguards of investigation and the hearing of the employee's statements, which we set out in our article on disciplinary penalties imposed without investigation. A related situation, where unexplained absence is treated as an implied resignation or a ground for dismissal, is covered in our article on absence from work.

8. Evidence the employee should gather

A challenge to a rating is really a contest of comparison, and the evidence that tips the balance is usually the following.

  • Earlier efficiency reports: if they held steadily at a high rating for years and then dropped suddenly for no apparent reason, that is the strongest indication of the absence of a basis. Ask for copies from the personnel file.
  • Documented achievements: thank-you letters, certificates, training records, progress reports, completed projects and correspondence showing work delivered on time.
  • Attendance and discipline records: if the report mentions absence or lateness, obtain the actual attendance record that refutes it or fixes its extent.
  • The absence of warnings or written remarks: an employee rated weak who was never warned in writing about any shortcoming during the year can rely on that absence as evidence that the reduction did not follow a serious assessment.
  • Evidence of a quarrel or personal motive: earlier mutual complaints, a refusal to follow an improper instruction followed by a lowered rating, or statements by the superior that reveal a personal stance. This evidence gains value when arranged in a clear timeline.
  • Comparison with colleagues in similar circumstances: to be used carefully; the court may ask the entity for what is needed.
  • Witnesses among colleagues or former superiors: usually less important than documents in this type of case, but they reinforce the picture when documents are incomplete.

Above all, keep a copy of the grievance, the receipt showing its registration and the entity's reply, if any, since these prove that deadlines were met and that procedure was followed.

Principles of the Court of Cassation

In disputes involving public employees, the Court of Cassation has consistently held a number of principles governing challenges to administrative decisions, which may be drawn on here in their general substance:

  • The administrative authority has discretion in assessing the competence of its employees, and judicial review of that is review of legality, not of appropriateness, so the judge does not take the administration's place in judging the level of performance.
  • An administrative decision must rest on a sound cause justified by the facts and the law, and the court may verify that the factual circumstances on which it was built exist and that they were correctly characterised in law.
  • Misuse of power is a defect of intent that concerns the purpose of the decision; the burden of proving it lies on the person asserting it, and it may be inferred from concurring circumstantial evidence arising from the circumstances in which the decision was issued.
  • Administrative decisions carry a presumption of validity, and the challenger must produce what rebuts it, without relieving the entity of the duty to produce the papers in its hands that bear on the dispute when the court requires them.
  • Time limits for grievances and challenges to administrative decisions concern public order, the court applies them on its own motion, and missing them results in the case being inadmissible in form.
  • Actual and comprehensive knowledge of the decision, including its content and grounds, is what starts the challenge period where there has been no formal notification, and the burden of proving the date of knowledge lies on the entity that relies on lateness.

Methodological note: we deliberately omit appeal numbers and judgment dates, because citing a judgment accurately requires its full text and facts. These principles are stated in their generally settled form. When drafting a statement of claim, the lawyer reviews the most recent judgments on the specific issue, since the courts' approach can shift with legislative amendment or developments in case law.

Practical Steps and Documents

If you receive an efficiency rating you consider weak or unfair, these steps protect your position.

  • Read the whole report: take a copy or photograph, and identify the elements where marks were reduced and any written remarks.
  • Do not refuse to sign as having seen it: sign only as having seen it and write "I am grieving this rating," to avoid the entity counting your knowledge from the date of presentation without your signature.
  • File the grievance in writing and on time: with the committee or authority named in the regulations, by a means that fixes the date, and keep a copy stamped as received.
  • Attach your documents: earlier reports, certificates, thank-you letters, progress reports, attendance records and work correspondence.
  • Await the reply within the prescribed period: if the grievance is rejected expressly or the entity stays silent, count the time for suit from the date of rejection or from the end of the period allowed for reply, and consult a lawyer promptly to fix these dates.
  • Prepare the statement of claim: filed through a lawyer before the Administrative Circuit of the Court of First Instance, asking for annulment of the rating and the decisions built on it, a stay of execution where needed, and compensation where there is harm.
  • Ask the court to require the entity to produce the evaluation file: including the report form, the papers behind its preparation, the earlier reports and the documents on which the reduction was based.

Documents usually required: a copy of the report in dispute, copies of earlier reports, a copy of the grievance with proof of submission and the entity's reply if any, the promotion or increment decision affected by the rating, qualification and experience certificates, and any correspondence showing a personal motive or the absence of remarks.

Hypothetical Scenarios

Scenario one: high ratings for years, then a sudden drop

An employee in a finance department held the top rating for several consecutive years, then received a weak rating after she complained about her new manager's allocation of tasks. Her file contains no warning or written remark for the entire year, and the manager had changed only a few months before the evaluation. She grieves to the competent committee and presents her record, her thank-you letters, the absence of any remark, and the order of events between the complaint and the rating. If the grievance is rejected, the court may examine the indicators of misuse of power: the timing, the lack of justification and the abrupt shift. These indicators reinforce one another, and none is sufficient alone.

Scenario two: a weak rating followed by being passed over for promotion

An employee who qualified for promotion by seniority was passed over for a more junior colleague, the entity citing his latest weak rating. He challenges two things together: the efficiency rating on which the entity relied, and the promotion decision that passed him over. The court's question becomes whether the rating was correct and founded on a cause. If the rating falls, so does the justification the entity used for the comparison. He may also present his earlier reports and qualifications to show that he was the better candidate, as we discussed in our article on promotion of a more junior colleague.

Scenario three: a rating that was never shown to the employee

An employee discovers, while reviewing his file for another purpose, that last year's report is weak. It was never presented to him or signed by him, and his increment was withheld because of it. For him the time for grievance runs from the date of his actual knowledge of the rating, not from when it was prepared, and the burden of showing that he knew earlier rests on the entity. He files a grievance immediately and documents the date of his discovery, arguing that failing to present the report to him breached an essential procedure. Speed is still the safer course, because the entity may argue that he knew earlier by other means, such as a pay slip or earlier letters.

Quick Comparison of Situations

  • A weak rating resting on genuine, documented shortcomings with earlier warnings: likely to stand because it falls within the administration's discretion; the employee is advised to grieve on the merits before the committee rather than rely on the court.
  • A sudden weak rating with no written remarks and no change in performance: a strong position for grievance and challenge, for lack of cause or arbitrariness.
  • A weak rating that followed a complaint or a dispute with the superior: raises an inference of misuse of power but needs evidence and a timeline.
  • A weak rating never shown to the employee: supports the plea of procedural breach and affects the counting of deadlines in the employee's favour.
  • A weak rating followed by being passed over for promotion or an increment being withheld: challenging both decisions together is the safest course in form and substance.
  • A weak rating used as a pretext for transfer or sidelining: brings the transfer within the challenge on grounds of arbitrariness, with the evidence added.
  • A rating approved by a committee after specific written reasons: harder to challenge, because the administration offers an apparent justification, and the claimant must show that the facts themselves are wrong.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an employee object to the rating of his or her efficiency?

Yes. The employee may grieve the rating through the route set by the regulations and, if not given redress, challenge the final decision and what was built on it before the Administrative Circuit. The administration holds the power of assessment, but that power is subject to review for legality.

Can the court raise my rating from average to good, for example?

As a rule the judge does not take the administration's place in judging the level of performance. If a defect in the rating is proved, the court annuls it and the entity reconsiders in line with the judgment; the court does not ordinarily award a particular grade. An internal committee, by contrast, may review the rating on the merits depending on the regulations.

What if the report was never presented to me and I never signed it?

Failure to present it is a breach of procedure that can be relied on, and it affects when the time limits start, since they run from actual knowledge. The burden of proving earlier knowledge lies on the entity, but you should still act as soon as you discover the rating and document the date.

Does my signature as having seen the report mean I accept the rating?

No. Signing as having seen it is evidence of reading only and is neither acceptance nor a waiver of the right to grieve. It is better to write beside it that you are grieving and to keep a copy.

Is a grievance required before filing suit?

In employment disputes with the state, an administrative grievance usually has to be pursued before suit, as the law and regulations provide. Skipping it where it is required exposes the claim to being dismissed as inadmissible. It is safest not to omit it, and to ask a lawyer whether it is required on your facts.

Can the report itself be challenged, or only the decision based on it?

Approaches differ depending on how the report is characterised and its effect on the legal position, and the court's assessment turns on the facts of each case. The prudent course is to challenge the rating and every decision that followed from it together.

What is the effect of a weak rating on the periodic increment?

The regulations link the increment to the rating level, so a lower rating may prevent or delay it, depending on the rule that applies to the employee. If an unfair rating is annulled, entitlement is reconsidered in line with the judgment, and the differences due are calculated as the judgment and the financial rules require.

Does a weak rating absolutely bar promotion?

Not necessarily. Promotion has several conditions and the rating is one of them. It may nevertheless be a bar or a factor against you in the comparison, depending on the regulation, though it does not excuse the entity from observing the other conditions. We treated being passed over for promotion in a separate article referred to above.

How do I prove misuse of power?

Through concurring circumstantial evidence: the timing of the rating after a complaint or a dispute, a sudden unexplained fall, the absence of any earlier written remark, and statements or correspondence that reveal the motive. It is among the hardest defects to prove, and a mere feeling that the superior harbours something is not enough.

Must I accept the consequences of the rating while I challenge it?

As a rule administrative decisions are carried out and are not suspended merely because they are challenged, unless the court orders a stay of execution on proof of its conditions. Keep performing your duties regularly: a breach would hand the entity a fresh justification it may seize on.

Can I claim compensation as well as annulment?

Yes, if you show that the decision is defective, that you suffered harm because of it and that the two are causally linked. The judge assesses compensation according to the circumstances, and annulment alone does not always repair the harm.

What if the entity ignores my grievance?

Silence on a grievance beyond the period fixed by law is treated as an implied rejection, and a suit may be based on it. We explained this in our article on the negative administrative decision and implied refusal; consult it to count the time limits correctly.

Does this apply to employees of bodies with special pay scales?

Some bodies are governed by special evaluation and promotion regulations whose details differ, but the general principles of legality, such as a sound cause, no misuse of power and correct procedure, apply to administrative decisions generally. The special regulation must be examined before the route and the time limits are fixed.

Conclusion

The annual efficiency report is not a passing form: it is the foundation on which an employee's financial and career rights are built over years. It is therefore unwise to dismiss it or to surrender to an unfair rating on the footing that it is simply "the superior's opinion." The administration holds the power of assessment, but exercises it within the limits of legality: proper competence, sound procedure, established facts and a lawful purpose, which is the public interest.

The prudent employee begins by reading the report and not refusing to acknowledge it, then files a written grievance backed by evidence through the route the regulations lay down, a route that may end in redress without any litigation. If that fails, the Administrative Circuit is open, with a statement of claim that joins the challenge to the rating with the decisions built on it, and with organised evidence comparing the employee's work history with the latest rating.

In the end, a challenge succeeds or fails on practical matters: speed of action, accuracy in counting deadlines, the strength of the career record, and the correct characterisation of the facts as arbitrariness, misuse of power or want of cause. We stress that the principles here are general, that each entity has its own regulations and each case its own details.

Legal Notice

This article provides general legal information about Kuwaiti law. It is not legal advice and does not create a relationship between the reader and the firm. The provisions described are subject to legislative amendment and to judicial application on the facts of each case.

If you have received an efficiency rating you believe is unfair, or you have been denied a promotion or an increment because of it, the team at Yumnak Law Firm can study your career file, prepare the grievance, and file and follow the challenge before the Administrative Circuit. Contact us through the Contact Us page or book an appointment at the office.

Need Legal Advice?

The Yumnaak Law Firm team is ready to help with trusted expertise.

Book Appointment Contact Us
Supporting Services
التوثيق
Tawtheeq & POA
poa.moj.gov.kw
وزارة العدل
MOJ eServices
eservices.moj.gov.kw
 KDIPA
Direct Investment Promotion Authority
kdipa.gov.kw
SYSLAWS
Made in Kuwait ♥
SYSLAWS.COM

All rights reserved to Yumnaak Law Firm 2026 YUMNAAK LAW FIRM