You walk out of a shopping mall after a few hours and find the window of your car smashed, a long scratch down the door that was not there when you parked, or an empty space where you were sure you left the vehicle. Two questions arrive at once: who did it, and who bears the loss? The answer to the second is not always "nobody", whatever the sign at the car park entrance may suggest.
This article deals with one narrow angle: damage to a vehicle, or its theft, inside the car park of a shopping mall or a building in Kuwait. Can the mall, the security company or the parking operator be held responsible, and how do you prove what happened and make a claim? Injuries to people who slip, fall or are hurt inside a mall, shop or restaurant are a different subject and are covered in our separate article, injury in a mall, shop or restaurant in Kuwait. We will not repeat it here.
We explain the difference between a free public car park and a paid or guarded one, what the sign "management is not responsible for lost items" really does, how proof is built from the police report, the surveillance footage and the guards' accounts, how comprehensive motor insurance and the insurer's right of recourse fit in, and what to do, and avoid doing, in the first hours after you discover the damage.
Quick Answer
Yes, the mall, the parking operator or the security company may be held responsible, but not automatically. Responsibility depends on whether the car actually came into the other party's custody (a paid car park with guards, entry and exit records and monitoring, or a valet service where the key is handed over), or whether the mall failed in a duty of guarding, lighting and monitoring that it undertook or that the nature of its business required, and on whether you can prove the incident and that it happened inside the car park.
An open, free car park with no guards, no fees and no control of entry is the weakest ground for a claim, because the relationship there looks more like a passing use of a space than a deposit of the car. A paid car park where your entry and exit are recorded, guards are posted and cameras operate is much stronger ground. The sign "management is not responsible" does not extinguish your claim on its own: it is examined in light of the real nature of the relationship, whether it became part of a genuine agreement, and the principle that an exclusion generally does not reach fraud or gross fault.
In every case, move quickly on three things: an official police report and photographs of the scene before the car is moved, a written request to the mall's management to preserve camera footage, and notice to your insurer if you hold a comprehensive policy. Do not sign any document containing a release or waiver until you know the true extent of the damage and your position with the insurer.
Legislative Framework
Kuwait has no stand-alone "car park law" that governs a mall's liability for vehicles. The rules come from the general law, spread over several statutes that work together:
- The Civil Code (Decree-Law No. 67 of 1980): the main source. It contains the general rule on liability in tort (whoever commits a fault that causes harm to another must compensate it), the rules of contract and the obligations to take care or to achieve a result, the provisions on deposit and lease that are used to characterise the relationship between a car owner and a parking operator, the liability of one who has the guard of things requiring special care, and the liability of a principal for the acts of an agent or employee.
- The Penal Code (Law No. 16 of 1960): criminalises theft, damage and vandalism and is used against whoever took the car, smashed the glass or deliberately damaged it. We discuss theft offences in theft crimes under Kuwaiti law.
- The Code of Criminal Procedure (Law No. 17 of 1960): governs the receipt of complaints, investigation, evidence gathering and referral of the case. It is the route by which the criminal case over the incident is opened.
- The Law of Evidence in Civil and Commercial Matters (Law No. 39 of 1980): sets out who bears the burden of proof and which means are admitted: writing, witnesses, presumptions, inspection and expert evidence. A civil claim for compensation stands on it.
- The Electronic Transactions Law (Law No. 20 of 2014): deals with the evidential value of electronic records and documents, which matters for camera recordings, electronic entry tickets and digital parking logs.
- The Law on Combating Information Technology Crimes (Law No. 63 of 2015): protects people's privacy against the publication of images and clips. It has a practical consequence when a victim is tempted to post camera footage on social media rather than hand it to the competent authorities.
- The Insurance Regulation Law (Law No. 125 of 2019): regulates insurers and is the general reference for the relationship between you and your insurer when you claim for damage or theft under a comprehensive policy.
- The Consumer Protection Law (Law No. 39 of 2014): may be relevant where parking is offered as a paid service to consumers, since unfair terms and misleading notices fall under its oversight.
The insurance side is covered in more detail in two earlier articles: comprehensive and third-party insurance in Kuwait and vehicle insurance in Kuwait.
Substantive Rules
First: a free public car park, or a paid or guarded one?
The question that decides more than any other is this: did the guard of the car pass to the mall or the operator, or did it stay in your hands? Simply parking in a space owned by someone else does not make that person automatically liable for everything that happens to the car, and a guard standing at the gate does not necessarily mean he has taken charge of your car.
In an open, free public car park, where your car is not registered, your entry is not recorded and nobody controls entry and exit, the position approaches the use of an open space made available to the public as an adjunct to the mall's business. The clearest route to a claim there is to prove a specific fault on the part of the mall or the security company: for example, lighting that was out in a known risk area, cameras that had been broken for a long time and not repaired, guards absent from a car park the mall had undertaken to guard, or repeated similar incidents that had been reported and not dealt with. The burden of proving fault, damage and the causal link lies on the claimant.
In a paid car park with guards and monitoring, or one where the key is handed to the person who parks the car, the idea that the operator took the vehicle into its custody, or undertook to look after it for a fee, is much stronger. The relationship is then treated as close to a deposit for reward, or a contract containing an obligation of guarding, and the standard of care is higher. If the car is not returned in the condition in which it was handed over, it is for the operator to prove that it exercised due care or that the damage came from an external cause for which it was not responsible. Whether the arrangement is a deposit, a lease or a mere licence to use a space is characterised by the court on the facts of each case: what was handed over, what was paid, what guarding the car park really provides, and what the ticket and the notices say.
The practical indicators are simple. Is there a ticket showing the date and time of entry? Must it be produced or a fee paid on exit? Is the licence plate recorded? Are there guards or monitors at the gates and in the aisles? Was the key handed over? Each "yes" strengthens your argument that the operator assumed an obligation to look after the vehicle.
Second: the sign "management is not responsible for lost items"
A sign at the entrance, or text printed on the back of a ticket, does not by itself mean that you gave up your rights. Several considerations govern its effect:
- Its subject matter: the word "lost items" on its face refers to belongings left in the car or forgotten, not to the car itself where it was handed over or came into the operator's custody. Such a clause is read narrowly because an exclusion of liability is an exception to the rule.
- Its source: if the sign is merely a one-sided announcement that the car owner never expressly accepted and that was not part of a genuine agreement, its presence alone is not enough to make it a binding term. If it is written on a ticket that was handed to you and accepted, the analysis differs.
- The limits of exclusion: an agreement to exclude or limit contractual liability is generally permitted within limits, but it does not extend to fraud or gross fault and is not applied in favour of someone who deliberately caused harm. The rule for excusing a person from the consequences of his own direct tortious fault is much narrower still.
- Public policy and consumer protection: terms that empty a core obligation of its content, for example charging a fee for guarding and then declaring no responsibility for anything, contradict the very nature of the service and may be treated as unfair terms.
So the sign is not the end of the story, but do not ignore it either. Photograph it and record its place and wording; the court may need it to understand what the mall was announcing to the public and what it actually undertook.
Third: the mall's responsibility for guarding, lighting and monitoring
A business that draws the public to its premises and opens car parks within its grounds should provide a reasonable degree of safety and guarding, in line with the nature, size and footfall of the place. In general terms, a failing may be attributed to the mall if facts of this kind are established: lighting that is out or weak in parking areas, cameras that do not work or do not cover entrances and aisles, guarding that was advertised and not provided, laxity in controlling entry and exit despite repeated crimes at the site, or no response to earlier reports of similar thefts.
Several parties may be the target of a claim: the mall as the owner of the premises, the security company it engaged, the parking operator if a separate company, and possibly the landlord if different from the operator. Each has its own contract and its own responsibilities. Where the mall's management has contracted a security company, that does not usually prevent the injured party from claiming against the owner of the premises as the party that undertook to secure the car park, nor does it prevent the mall from seeking recourse against the security company under their contract. The idea is related to the liability of a principal for the faults of those who work for him, explained in liability for the acts of others under Kuwaiti law: a guard who works for a security company and fails in his duty while on the job engages the responsibility of his principal.
On the other hand, a mall is not liable for every crime that occurs on its grounds. If it shows that it took what the circumstances required by way of guarding, lighting and monitoring, and that the offender nevertheless succeeded in a way that could not have been foreseen or prevented, the failing may fall away. The claim is therefore built on provable facts, not merely on the fact that a crime happened somewhere the defendant owns.
Fourth: comprehensive insurance and the insurer's recourse
If your car carries comprehensive insurance, the policy will usually cover theft, broken glass and damage caused by an unknown party, according to its terms and exclusions. This gives you a faster route than waiting for a lawsuit against the mall. That route has its own rules:
- Notice and report: policies usually require prompt notice to the insurer and a police report or official statement of the theft or vandalism. Delay or a neglected report may be used against you to refuse the claim.
- Exclusions: the insurer will check whether the car was locked, whether the keys were left inside, whether the policy was in force and the driver's licence valid, and whether personal belongings inside the car are covered or only the car itself. We explained how insurers refuse compensation for breach of policy conditions in insurer refusal of motor accident compensation.
- Subrogation: if the insurer pays you, it steps into your shoes in recourse against whoever is responsible for the loss, whether the offender if identified, or the mall or parking operator if its fault is established. Your rights against that party pass to the insurer to the extent of what it paid.
- The effect of waiver and settlement: because the insurer's right of recourse follows your own right, any release, waiver or settlement that you sign with the mall or operator before being compensated, or without the insurer's knowledge, may prejudice its recourse and, depending on the policy terms, may be raised against you. So do not sign anything that gives up a right before consulting your insurer and your lawyer.
- What the policy does not cover: you may keep a claim against the responsible party for the differences the insurer does not pay, such as the agreed excess, diminution in value of the car and the cost of a replacement vehicle, which we discussed in loss of value, downtime and replacement vehicle hire.
If your car carries only compulsory third-party insurance rather than comprehensive cover, that insurance does not compensate damage to your own car from theft or vandalism. Your route is then against the offender if identified, or against the mall if grounds for its responsibility exist.
Fifth: what must be proved, and how
Whether before the insurer or in court, the claim rests on four elements that you should have in mind from the first moment: that the incident occurred (theft or damage), that it occurred inside the car park (the time of entry and exit and the place of parking), the value of the loss (a repair report, or the market value of a stolen car), and the ground for holding the defendant responsible (its taking custody of the car, or its failure in guarding). Proof draws on the police report, the parking ticket, camera footage, statements by guards and witnesses, workshop reports, inspection and expert evidence.
Cassation Principles
The Court of Cassation has settled, in the principles relevant to this subject, that civil liability rests on proof of fault, damage and a causal link between them, and that assessing fault and characterising the relationship between the parties is a matter of fact for the trial court, provided its judgment is based on sound reasons. It has also settled that contracts are interpreted according to what the parties' intentions pointed to, that clauses excluding liability are interpreted narrowly and do not apply to fraud or gross fault, and that a person who receives a thing for reward is bound to look after it and return it, so that if it is lost or damaged he is excused only by proving an external cause.
It has likewise settled that the court has discretion in weighing the evidential value of video recordings and technical reports among the elements of the case, and that the police or the prosecution may file a complaint for want of an identified perpetrator without that preventing the right holder from bringing a civil action against whomever he considers civilly liable, provided the elements of that liability exist. And that an insurer's subrogation to the insured's rights against the party responsible is limited to what it has paid.
Methodological note: these principles are presented in the general form in which they are settled in Cassation case law, without case numbers or judgment dates. They are no substitute for checking recent precedents and applying them to the facts of each case, because the characterisation of the victim's relationship with the parking operator and the assessment of the mall's fault vary with the facts and documents.
Practical Steps and Documents
What to do immediately on discovering the damage
- Do not move the car and do not touch the damaged area: there may be fingerprints, broken glass or fragments that investigators can use.
- Photograph everything before any movement: the car from every side, the damage close up, the plate number, the parking spot and floor or zone number, the nearby lighting and cameras, the signs at the entrance and your parking ticket. Make sure the images show the date and time.
- Call the police and report officially: report to the police station of the area or the competent body and ask for a report that describes the incident and what was lost or damaged. In a theft, ask that the report record that the car was stolen from inside the car park and roughly when.
- Notify the mall's management or the operator in writing: ask to see the security manager, write a notice of the incident and its time, and obtain a stamped copy or acknowledgment of receipt. In the letter, ask expressly that camera recordings be preserved for the relevant day and period and not erased or recorded over, since many systems overwrite older footage after a short time.
- Collect the identity of guards and witnesses: the names of the guards on duty and their shift times, and the phone numbers of anyone who saw the incident or noticed a suspicious person.
- Notify your insurer if your policy is comprehensive, send the notice in a way that can be proved, and ask what documents it requires.
- Obtain a repair report or technical assessment from a reputable workshop or technical body before starting repairs, and keep the damaged parts if possible.
Surveillance cameras: how to request and preserve them
Camera recordings are the strongest evidence in many of these cases, but they are in the mall's possession, not yours. The mall is not usually bound to hand you the recording simply because you ask, for reasons of privacy and the protection of other visitors' data, and it may ask for an order from an official body. The safest path is therefore to ask in writing that the recording be preserved, and then ask the police or the prosecution to take it officially and add it to the case file, since they have the authority to seize and transcribe it. If the mall denies having a recording or claims that it was erased, that denial may itself be examined by the court, particularly if the system normally operates and your request reached them early. In the civil case the court may call on the mall to produce records and recordings under the rules of evidence.
If you do obtain the clip informally, keep an original copy exactly as delivered, without editing or trimming, and write a note of who delivered it and when. Avoid posting it on social media: publishing people's images or clips without permission may expose you to liability under the Law on Combating Information Technology Crimes, even if you are the victim.
Documents you will need
- The vehicle registration and the owner's identity, and the purchase contract or other proof of ownership.
- The police report or case number and a copy of the report.
- The parking ticket, payment receipt or any proof of entry and exit.
- The photographs and videos you took of the car, the site and the signs.
- Correspondence with the mall or the security company, the acknowledgment of your notice and your request to preserve recordings.
- The insurance policy, your notice to the insurer and its reply.
- The repair report or damage assessment, or proof of the value of the stolen car, and receipts for items stolen from inside it if any.
- Names and numbers of witnesses and guards.
The road to a claim
The path usually begins with a formal written notice to the mall or the operator describing the incident, the amount claimed and its basis. If friendly correspondence fails, a civil action for compensation is brought before the competent court. It can be accompanied by a request that the mall be ordered to produce recordings and records, and a request for an expert to assess the loss. At the same time the criminal case, if the offender is identified or emerges from the investigation, proceeds on its own track. Where the offender is known, you may claim your civil right within the criminal case or in a separate civil action. Negotiation and settlement before litigation are discussed in our article on amicable settlement of a road accident without a traffic report; the risks described there apply in a similar way here.
Three Hypothetical Cases
Case one: broken glass in an open, free car park
Khalid parks at an open mall car park with no ticket, no barriers and no fee. When he returns he finds the window smashed and his bag gone. He reports to the police, photographs the site and writes to the mall asking it to preserve the recordings of the area. It turns out that the lighting in that area had been out for some time and that earlier complaints about similar incidents were logged. Khalid has no deposit contract and no custody to rely on, so he builds his claim on the mall's failure in lighting and monitoring after it knew of repeated crimes, and keeps his civil claim alongside his report. If he has comprehensive cover, he goes to his insurer first. Proving the lighting failure and the earlier reports is the key to his case.
Case two: a paid car park with ticket and guards, and a stolen car
Sara enters a paid car park in a commercial building, receives a ticket showing the time of entry, and there are guards and cameras at the entrance and exit. On her return she cannot find her car. She reports to the police and to the car park management and shows the police her ticket. This is closer to custody for reward: the car entered a registered, guarded car park, and it is for the operator to prove that it took due care or that the theft happened for a reason beyond its control. Sara can claim from her comprehensive insurer to recover the value of the car, and the insurer steps into her place in recourse against the operator. The sign "not responsible for lost items" is unlikely to help the operator here because the car itself is the subject of the deposit.
Case three: a scratch on the door and an early waiver
Fahd finds a deep scratch on his comprehensively insured car in a mall car park. The mall's management offers to compensate him immediately on condition that he signs a full release, and he signs before notifying his insurer. Later the insurer rejects part of the claim, arguing that his signing the release destroyed its right of recourse against the mall. The case shows why one must never sign a release before notifying the insurer and knowing the full extent of the damage, and how a settlement that looks quick can turn into an additional dispute.
Quick Comparison
- Open, free public car park: no recorded entry and no custody. The claim rests on proving a specific failing (lighting, monitoring, guarding that was advertised but not provided). The burden of proof lies on the victim. The stronger option is usually comprehensive insurance, if you have it.
- Paid, guarded or entry-recorded car park: there is an obligation to look after the car for reward. The claim is stronger, and the operator must prove due care or an external cause. The ticket and receipt are key evidence.
- Valet service with handover of the key: custody is clear, and the operator's responsibility for the car from receipt to return is at its highest.
- The sign "not responsible for lost items": read narrowly, may not cover the car itself, does not excuse fraud or gross fault, and may be treated as an unfair term in a paid service.
- Comprehensive insurance: a faster route to compensation, with the insurer stepping into your shoes in recourse, provided you give notice, report the incident and do not waive your rights beforehand.
- Compulsory third-party insurance only: does not cover damage to your own car from theft or vandalism, so the route remains against the offender or the mall.
- The official report: a practical necessity before the insurer and before the court, but on its own it does not make the mall liable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a mall always responsible for my car stolen from its car park?
No. Liability depends on the nature of the car park, the relationship and the facts. If the car came into the operator's custody (a paid, guarded and recorded car park, or a handover of the key) the case for liability is stronger. If the car park is open and free, you must prove a specific failing in guarding, lighting or monitoring.
Does the sign "management is not responsible for lost items" exempt the mall from compensation?
It is not sufficient on its own. It is read narrowly, does not usually extend to a car that was handed over or came into the operator's custody, does not extend to fraud or gross fault, and may not be binding at all if it was not part of a genuine agreement. The judge assesses its effect on the facts of each case.
What is the difference between a free and a paid car park for a claim?
In a paid, recorded and guarded car park, the idea of an obligation to look after the car for reward arises, so proof is easier for you and the operator must show due care. In a free open car park, the claim turns on proving a specific tortious failing by the mall.
Must I file a police report?
Yes, it is the essential step. It establishes the incident, its time and place, insurers usually require it for theft and vandalism, it opens the criminal case and allows the camera recordings to be seized officially. It should be made immediately and should state that the incident took place inside the mall's car park.
How do I ask for the camera recordings to be preserved?
Write to the mall's management or security asking expressly that the recording of the relevant period be kept and not erased, keep a stamped copy or acknowledgment of receipt, and ask the police or the prosecution to seize it officially. Recordings may be overwritten automatically after a time, and speed makes the difference.
Is the mall obliged to give me the clip?
Usually it is not obliged to hand it to you personally, since it contains other people's images. But official bodies can request and seize it, and in the civil case the court may order its production. If it is given to you informally, keep an original copy and do not publish it.
Should I post the clip on social media to pressure the mall?
This is not advisable. Publishing people's images or clips without permission may expose you to liability under the Law on Combating Information Technology Crimes and weaken your position in court. Give it to the competent authorities and to the court.
My car has comprehensive insurance. Do I wait for the result of a case against the mall?
There is no need. After the police report, notify your insurer as the policy requires; it steps into your shoes in recourse against the responsible party after it pays. Even so, do not sign any waiver or release in favour of the mall before coordinating with the insurer.
Does compulsory third-party insurance cover the theft of my car or the breaking of its glass?
No. Compulsory insurance covers what your vehicle causes to others, not the damage to your own vehicle. Cover for theft and vandalism usually comes from a comprehensive policy, according to its terms and exclusions. We explained the difference above and in our earlier article on comprehensive and third-party insurance.
The insurer rejected my claim because I left the key in the car or did not lock it. Do I have a right?
The precise wording of the policy is reviewed, including whether the condition is clear and was accepted and whether the exclusion applies to your facts. The insured may object, complain and then go to court. For more, see our article on insurer refusal of compensation.
A guard took my key and parked the car, and I later found it damaged. Who is responsible?
When the operator receives the key and parks the car, custody exists, and the operator is bound to return the car undamaged or prove an external cause. Photographing the car's condition at handover and at collection, and obtaining a receipt, protects your right.
Can I claim directly from the security company?
A claim may be directed at whoever is shown to be responsible on the facts: the mall, the operator, the security company, or more than one of them, jointly in some situations. A company answers for the failing of its guards while they work, as explained above in the discussion of liability for the acts of others.
Can I claim for items stolen from inside the car?
You may, if you prove their existence and value, but proof is harder, and coverage under a comprehensive policy depends on the policy terms. The expression "lost items" has more weight here than it does for the car itself.
Can I claim for a replacement car and the loss of value?
An injured party may be entitled to compensation wider than the cost of repair if he proves his other losses such as downtime and diminution in value, and the court has discretion in assessing it. We covered this in loss of value, downtime and replacement vehicle hire.
What if I sold the car before the incident and ownership was never transferred?
A claim becomes complicated when the registered owner does not match the actual possessor, which raises the question of who bears obligations and losses. We dealt with the effect of an untransferred title in I sold my car and the buyer did not transfer ownership.
The damage happened to my Kuwaiti car in a car park in another Gulf country. Is the answer the same?
The competent forum, the applicable law and the insurance cover differ for incidents outside Kuwait, so the rules above should not be applied to car parks abroad without checking. See our article on a road accident in another Gulf state with your Kuwaiti car.
A person was hurt in the same incident in the car park. Does that change things?
Yes. Injury to persons has different rules on proof and liability, and we have a separate article on it: injury in a mall, shop or restaurant.
Conclusion
As a rule, a car park that a mall opens for its customers is a service tied to its business, and its owner should not use a notice on the wall as a shield against every claim. But the law does not make every business owner the guarantor of every car that stands on its grounds. It weighs the relationship, the handover of the car, the failing and the proof.
That is why what decides most of these cases is your speed and discipline in the first hours: clear photographs before the car is moved, an official report, written correspondence to preserve the recordings, notice to the insurer, and refusal to sign any release. Whoever does these things properly has a file that can support a claim, whether through the insurer or through the courts.
If your car has been stolen or damaged inside a car park and you wish to understand your position against the mall, the operator or your insurer, the better course is to put the facts and documents before a lawyer before signing any paper or accepting any offer.
Legal Notice
This article is general legal information and is no substitute for advice on the facts and documents of your own case. The nature of the car park, the terms of the ticket, the clauses of the policy and the evidence available may change the outcome fundamentally.
If you need your file reviewed or a notice or claim drafted, you can contact us or book an appointment at the office.