Private property is constitutionally protected — but the Constitution itself permits its expropriation for public utility in return for fair compensation. Law No. 33 of 1964 (as amended) regulates expropriation and temporary requisition procedures.
Contents
1) The Concept of Expropriation
- Definition: an administrative procedure by which the state transfers ownership of private real property to the public domain — compulsorily — to achieve a public utility.
- Exceptional measure: expropriation is an exception to the protection of private property — and is strictly construed.
- Real property only: expropriation applies to real property — not movables.
- Public utility: the expropriation must be for a project of genuine public utility — such as roads, hospitals, and public facilities.
2) Conditions
- Public utility: the expropriation must be for a project of public benefit — determined by decree.
- Necessity: no alternative means of achieving the utility without affecting private property.
- Fair compensation: the owner must receive fair compensation equal to the property's true value.
- Prior compensation: compensation should ideally be paid before possession — or deposited with the public treasury.
- Decree: a decree declaring the public utility and identifying the properties to be expropriated.
3) Procedures
- Decree: issuance of a decree declaring the project's public-utility status.
- Survey: surveying the required properties and identifying their owners.
- Notification: notifying owners of the expropriation decision and requesting their documentation.
- Valuation: valuing the properties through a valuation committee.
- Negotiation: attempting to reach an amicable agreement with owners on compensation.
- Court: if agreement fails, the matter is referred to court for compensation assessment.
4) Valuation and Compensation
Valuation criteria
- Market value of the property at the time of expropriation.
- Location, area, and use of the property.
- Prevailing prices in the area.
- Damage resulting from expropriation (loss of income, relocation costs).
Compensation elements
- Value of land and buildings.
- Compensation for structures and improvements.
- Compensation for damages resulting from expropriation.
- Interest for delay if compensation payment is late.
5) Temporary Requisition
- Definition: the state's temporary taking of possession of a property for an urgent project — without transferring ownership.
- Duration: for a specified period — ownership is returned after the need ends.
- Compensation: the owner is compensated for the period of requisition and any damage to the property.
- Conversion: if requisition continues for an extended period, it converts to full expropriation with full compensation.
6) Challenging the Decision
- Administrative challenge: challenging the public-utility decree before the Administrative Division if the public-utility requirement is not met.
- Valuation challenge: objecting to the assessed compensation before the Court of First Instance.
- Expert: the court may appoint an expert to re-assess the value.
- Appeal: the first-instance judgment may be appealed to the Court of Appeal.
7) Effects of Expropriation
- Transfer: ownership transfers to the state after payment or deposit of compensation.
- Extinction of rights: all in rem rights over the property lapse — such as mortgage and long lease.
- Rights-holders' compensation: holders of in rem rights are compensated from the compensation amount.
- Non-execution: if the project is not executed within five years, the owner may request return of their property.
8) Practical Guidance
If your property is expropriated
- Do not immediately accept the offered compensation — have it independently valued.
- Object in writing if compensation is below market value.
- Verify that a valid decree declaring public utility was issued.
- Appoint a lawyer specialising in expropriation cases.
Your rights
- Fair compensation is a constitutional right — do not waive it.
- Delay interest is legally owed.
- Right of recovery if the project is not executed.
- Right to challenge at every stage of the decision.